Key treaty articles
- Article 7 (Business Profits): business profits taxable only in country of residence unless US permanent establishment
- Article 10 (Dividends): 5% to corporate parent (10%+ ownership), 15% otherwise
- Article 11 (Interest): 0% on most interest
- Article 12 (Royalties): 0% on most royalties
- Article 4 (Residence): tie-breaker rules
The Canada-LLC issue
The CRA may treat a US LLC as a corporation for Canadian tax purposes (rather than pass-through), even though the IRS treats it as disregarded entity. This can result in double taxation: US taxes the LLC, then Canada also taxes the LLC distribution as a dividend. Canadian residents considering a US business should consider a C-Corp instead (consistently treated as corporation by both countries) or consult a Canadian CPA specializing in cross-border tax.
How to claim treaty benefits
- File Form W-8BEN-E with each US payer
- Line 5: Country of residence = Canada
- Part III: Cite Article 10, 11, or 12
- Line 8: LLC EIN as US TIN
- Line 9: Canadian SIN (optional)
- Renew every 3 years